SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) — The Alcatraz go to by Trump administration officers has obtained a powerful response from members of varied communities right here within the Bay Space.
Save the Bay Government Director David Lewis spoke to ABC7 Information about the opportunity of Alcatraz being turned again right into a federal jail.
He stated it may trigger a spread of environmental points but in addition addressed the intense challenges, together with: a scarcity of sewage and energy strains, the necessity for every part to be transported onto the island, and a crumbling infrastructure.
RELATED: AG Pam Bondi visits Alcatraz amid Trump’s proposal to reopen; Pelosi blasts ‘stupidest’ concept
“It might be loopy to attempt to construct a jail on the market. Ridiculously costly, harmful and likewise not good for the Bay,” Lewis stated.
Past the logistical points, there’s additionally a cultural significance that makes this concept unpopular amongst some Bay Space residents.
“Alcatraz is a crucial a part of our historical past. It is a place to begin for our rights and our up to date motion for self-determination,” stated Julian Courageous NoiseCat.
NoiseCat is a Native American author and director.
Again in 2019, he helped manage a canoe journey across the island on Indigenous Peoples’ Day.
NoiseCat says Alcatraz stays critically essential to many Indigenous People, in addition to their imaginative and prescient for what the U.S. ought to stand for.
RELATED: Trump says he’ll reopen infamous Alcatraz jail in San Francisco
“A imaginative and prescient for plurality, range and for honoring the founding commitments of this nation, together with the treaties with the over 500 native nations that referred to as the US house,” NoiseCat stated.
Others within the metropolis fear in regards to the impression closing Alcatraz to the general public may have on town’s financial system.
Edward Siu runs a journey company in Chinatown.
He tells us Alcatraz is among the most requested points of interest for each international and home vacationers in San Francisco.
He says if that goes away, his enterprise would endure.
“The island proper now’s for the vacationers. Now we have plenty of enterprise, plenty of tour enterprise to deliver over there. It is part of revenue to us. Why would they lower it off?” stated Siu.
A view additionally shared by many guests.
Exterior Alcatraz Metropolis Cruises, we met Sylvia Sanchez and her daughter Annie, who say they got here to San Francisco simply to see Alcatraz.
Sanchez tells us she thinks that as an alternative of changing the island, the president can be higher off reopening different services.
“The place I am from, there are many prisons on the market which might be deserted that he may make the most of,” stated Sanchez.
Copyright © 2025 KGO-TV. All Rights Reserved.
