Join The Transient, The Texas Tribune’s every day e-newsletter that retains readers up to the mark on probably the most important Texas information.
Two years after a district court docket declared {that a} new state regulation diluting the policy-making energy of blue city areas was unconstitutional, an appeals court docket on Friday overruled that call.
Texas lawmakers in 2023 handed Home Invoice 2127, dubbed the “Loss of life Star” invoice by opponents, which goals to overturn cities’ progressive insurance policies and forestall them from enacting future ordinances that are not aligned with broad swaths of state regulation.
The regulation prevents cities and counties from creating native ordinances that overstep state legal guidelines, similar to these handed in Dallas and Austin mandating water breaks for development employees.
The invoice, lengthy sought by Gov. Greg Abbott, marks Texas Republicans’ greatest try and undercut the ability of the state’s largest metropolitan areas, residence to probably the most Democratic-leaning constituents and leaders.
A month after the invoice handed, Houston, later joined by San Antonio and El Paso, sued the state to dam the brand new regulation, arguing that it disadvantaged elected officers of the ability to enact native ordinances on a broad vary of points, similar to noise rules and masks mandates. Additionally they have been involved that the regulation made it so tough for native leaders to self-govern that it might push them to suggest fewer coverage modifications.
“What this implies is that cities like town of Houston can’t move ordinances in these areas until the state of Texas explicitly offers us permission to take action,” late former Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner stated in 2023. “That may be a whole reversal from the best way issues have been on this state for greater than a century.”
A Travis County decide dominated in August 2023 that the regulation was unconstitutional, however on Friday the Third Court docket of Appeals overturned that call.
In its ruling, the appeals court docket stated it agrees with the state largely for 2 causes: the cities did not level to “adequate concreteness” of how the invoice would harm them, and made a weak case for a way the state is accountable for his or her issues.
The San Antonio metropolis lawyer’s workplace, nevertheless, famous that the court docket dismissed the case as a result of “cities haven’t got standing to problem” the regulation as a result of “at this level, there have been no challenges to any of our ordinances beneath this statute.”
Texas Republicans and enterprise lobbyists argued that the regulation works to untangle a complicated patchwork of native rules that burden companies and sluggish financial development. After the invoice handed, Abbott stated the regulation prevents cities from being “capable of micromanage companies” that are “particularly driving up the prices for native companies.”
“We’re going to have one regulatory regime throughout your entire state on huge topic areas that may make the price of enterprise even decrease, the convenience of enterprise even higher,” Abbott later added.
Earlier this yr, lawmakers did not move Senate Invoice 2858, which sought so as to add tooth to the 2023 regulation by giving the Texas lawyer normal the ability to sue cities and counties for adopting native guidelines overstepping state legal guidelines.
The San Antonio metropolis lawyer’s workplace stated it’s within the means of reviewing authorized choices and is coordinating with Houston and El Paso to plan out subsequent steps.
“Whereas this choice dismissed the present case, it would not forestall us from elevating these constitutional points once more sooner or later if a selected problem arises beneath HB 2127,” the workplace stated.
Joshua Fechter contributed to this report.
This text initially appeared in The Texas Tribune at https://www.texastribune.org/2025/07/18/texas-legislature-death-star-law-city-ordinances-limits/.
The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and fascinating Texans on state politics and coverage. Study extra at texastribune.org.
