NEW YORK — A person on Lengthy Island grew up with a suspicion his total life that one thing wasn’t proper… that perhaps he wasn’t in the best household. Then, his sister took a DNA check, and people suspicions turned to fact… he had been mistakenly switched at delivery.
“My siblings joked that, you understand, you had been the mailman’s child or stuff like that,” Kevin McMahon stated. “It was simply an remark, like he does not look something like us.”
McMahon’s youthful siblings had been honest, had straight exhausting hair, blue eyes and freckles. McMahon had none of these traits.
“If this this occurred at the moment, my dad and mom would have went residence from the hospital and stated, ‘this baby is totally in contrast to us,’ they might begin to query it instantly,” he stated.
It was Could 1960, at Jamaica Hospital, when Kevin McMahon was issued a delivery certificates ending in 2710.
Ross McMahon was born inside hours, together with his delivery certificates ending in 2711.
The infants had been switched at delivery. McMahon is now suing Jamaica Hospital.
“They’re fully accountable,” McMahon stated. “They made one calamitous mistake, and it simply modified the whole course of my life.”
Jamaica Hospital declined to remark.
“They’re two Caucasian moms with the identical final identify, of their 30s, that each gave delivery to child boys on the identical hospital on the identical day inside two hours of one another,” stated lawyer Jeremy Schiowitz.
McMahon, pictured to the left within the picture beneath, discovered when his sister Carol obtained her Ancestry.com outcomes, which revealed an unknown organic brother.
The brother standing subsequent to Carol is Ross, the opposite child McMahon switched at delivery.
Ross is absolutely Kevin, and Kevin is absolutely Ross.
“She was so fearful, so anxious about telling me,” stated Kevin McMahon about when his sister advised him. “When she advised me, I could not course of data, I am like, I really feel nothing. Like, I truthfully, I’ve no emotions right here. I believe I used to be in form of a state of shock at that time.”
Cece Moore is a genetic genealogist at Parabon Nanolabs, and has been featured on “Discovering Your Roots” on PBS, and on the ABC collection “Genetic Detective.”
She says she’s seen dozens of circumstances like these within the U.S.
“It is so extremely unhappy that we’re seeing so many surprises like this by direct-to-consumer DNA testing,” she stated.
For Kevin McMahon, it solutions the long-held query of why it all the time felt like he was handled otherwise than his siblings.
“You already know, even with that data, it feels prefer it’s too late for me,” he stated. “It does not change something. It does not change my insecurities.”
Copyright © 2025 WABC-TV. All Rights Reserved.
